Holdings  > Holding Rationales  > Allstate Investment Analysis

Holding: ALL

epicadv [4395]

Start tracking!

You are not tracking epicadv.

Symbol Sector Return Exposure Trades Last Trade Status
ALL Property and Casualty Insurance -14.54% 
Long
6  27-Aug-08  Currently Holding
<< Previous Post     Next Post >>

31-Mar-08

Allstate Investment Analysis

Holding Rationale for ALL.

 

Valuation Completed: 3/28/08

Rating: Buy

Comments:  Well run company that generates a ton of cash flow.  The operating business continues to execute well.  Concerns about their investment portfolio, which are justified, have pushed this stock to an insanely cheap level.    

All in, this is one nasty looking portfolio.  I do not believe the current financial statements accurately reflect the risk profile.  I would make the following adjustments in order to establish a true fair value:

  -$1B of AAA private label MBS - Apply 5% haircut (50mm)

  -$1.4B Alt-A MBS marked at 95.  Adjust the mark to 80 - (210mm)

  -$568mm CDO marked at 80.  Adjust the mark to 60 - (114mm)

  -$7B CMBS - Apply 5% haircut (350mm)

  -$180mm credit cards marked at 85.  Adjust to 70 - (27mm)

  -$4.6B of non investment grade bonds - Apply 10% haircut (463mm)

  -$10.8B of mortgage loans - Apply 5% haircut (540mm)

The total result is a haircut to the portfolio of (1.754B)

After these charges and using an 11% discount rate, the portfolio is worth $52 - $4 above the current price.  In fact, to generate a portfolio value this is inline with the current stock market price, you would need to expect $2.5B of write downs beyond the 1.8B I have applied.

Knowing the investment portfolio is more valuable than the stock price and that an operating business with dominant market share and great free cash flow is being given to us for free, we must buy this stock.  Getting detailed, fair value ranges between $58-$75.  Since I can purchase these shares nearly 20% below the lower end of the range, obtain a portfolio worth nearly $52 and collect a dividend that is inline with the 10yr US Treasury, ALL will serve as a core portfolio holding and should be bought up until a price of $52.

Tagged Stocks: ALL

 

Posted at 10:27 in Holding Rationales  |   Permalink  |   Comments (0)     |  Top

AddThis Social Bookmark Button
 
 
 

Credibility in ALL

epicadv

ALL Long
Rank 17/19
Return -14.54% at 2008-08-28
Rank 17/19
Trades 6
Followers 848
 

Categories

Holding Rationales (56)

Market Report (25)

Watchlist Ideas (12)

Holding Tags

AAPL (6)

ABFS (1)

ADP (1)

ALL (3)

AMZN (4)

BAC (2)

BONT (1)

CB (1)

CFC (1)

CROX (1)

CYBS (1)

DBC (2)

DDM (1)

DIA (3)

DIS (1)

DXD (1)

EBAY (2)

EEM (1)

FBR (1)

GE (1)

GOOG (3)

GS (2)

HD (1)

HET (1)

JPM (2)

KSWS (1)

LEH (2)

LF (1)

MOT (2)

MS (2)

MVL (2)

NLS (1)

ORCL (1)

PFE (2)

POT (3)

RATE (1)

RIMM (4)

SHLD (1)

SLV (1)

STI (1)

SU (1)

TGT (1)

WFC (4)

WFMI (1)

WM (5)

XTO (3)

ZLC (1)

Watchlist Tags

HSY (1)

NOK (2)

 

Archives

Aug 2008 (19)

Jul 2008 (5)

Jun 2008 (3)

May 2008 (3)

Apr 2008 (4)

Mar 2008 (10)

Feb 2008 (4)

Jan 2008 (3)

Dec 2007 (5)

Nov 2007 (19)

Oct 2007 (19)

Sep 2007 (1)